The bill still needs to be approved by the U.S. Congress before it is signed into law by President Obama. Both the President and Congress have indicated their willingness to see the law passed. The original deadline for the transition to digital television was February 17th.

“Delaying the upcoming DTV switch is the right thing to do,” said Senate Commerce Committee Chairman Jay Rockefeller, D-W.Va., author of the bill to push back the deadline. “I firmly believe that our nation is not yet ready to make this transition at this time.”

It is presumed (details on the bill are not public yet) that the bill also allocates an additional $25 million in funding to The National Telecommunications and Information Administration, which is the government agency responsible for dispersing $40 discount coupons for set top CECB converter boxes. The converter boxes allow those with analog television sets to decode the DTV or HDTV signals for viewing, albeit with degraded picture and sound quality. To get on the waiting list for coupons, U.S. residents may call 1-888-DTV-2009 or visit the TV Converter Box Coupon Program at http://www.dtv2009.gov.

Up until today, the looming DTV transition deadline in February and the current shortage of coupons sent by the government had created a miniature black market for the items. Ads on Craigslist.Org and auctions on eBay had been demanding higher and higher prices. This should put a quick end to most of these ads, which were being quickly deleted by each of the two websites. It is currently against federal law for anyone to sell DTV converter coupons.

That being said, there is an excellent story written by a reporter for the Associated Press (AP) that is making the rounds in syndication this morning. It offers some great perspective as to why it is such a bad idea to push back the February 2009 switchover date to digital television (DTV).

One factor that the mainstream media has never brought-up before is just how much it is costing TV broadcasters to simulcast both digital and analog signals prior to the switchover date. According to the article, one ABC-TV affiliate spends in excess of $20,000 a month on electricity alone for the old analog transmitter, on top of what they are spending on electricity for their new HDTV transmitter. So, pushing the DTV switchover date back for four months could cost TV stations upwards of $80,000. That may be a drop in the bucket for TV stations in larger markets, but in markets like Humboldt County where margins for broadcasters are already razor thin, that kind of money is no trivial matter.

Another fascinating statistic… the waiting list for $40 digital television converter (CECB) coupons has swollen to 2.6 million people. At this rate, even the additional $25 million that the government is planning on putting into the coupon program may not be enough to satisfy consumer demand. So, if you aren’t yet on the waiting list and still need a DTV converter box coupon, you should get on the list right-away, because there likely will not be enough to go around for everyone.

You can read the original AP article HERE.

After penning a request to Congress two weeks ago to push back the official transition date to digital television, it seems that both the House and U.S. Senate are prepared to do just that. The below paragraph from Friday’s Washington Post pretty much sums it up:

“Key senators have reached a compromise on a bill that would delay the nation’s switch to all-digital television from next month until June 12. A vote on the legislation is expected early next week.”

As if that weren’t enough, there is also talk that an additional $250 Million may be on its way to help bail out the government’s $40 coupon program, which helps consumers to pay for CECB digital television converter boxes. Assuming that each person gets two $40 coupons, the $250 million might cover the cost of providing DTV converter boxes to the current backlog of coupon requests, which last numbered well over 1 million.

Of course, the companies that manufacture these DTV converter boxes will most likely be caught off-guard by these new developments, and there is just no telling whether or not they will resume production to the level where everyone will be able to find one before June.

So, it seems that next month’s deadline may be more than a bit anticlimactic. Of course, broadcasters still have the right to switch everything over to digital television and eliminate their analog signals at any time. The bill would only push back the date at which switching to DTV would be mandatory for TV stations. I expect that quite a few broadcasters will actually opt to stick with the February deadline, since it has been in the works for so long.

First of all, filling out the online form is easy. There are a minimal number of questions. You can fill out the entire form online at http://www.DTV209.gov . It takes only a few minutes. You can also call their toll-free number at 1-888-DTV-2009. You will be walked through the application status over the telephone. Either way, the application process asks pretty much the same questions, and you will get your coupons just as fast one way as the other.

There are some “catches” with the application process. Considering the fact that this program is administered by the federal government, the whole system runs fairly smoothly though. The biggest “catch” is the fact that if you want to get the coupons in the first place, YOU HAVE TO APPLY FOR THEM! You won’t get them automatically if you fail to apply. There are only a limited number of coupons that are being produced, although the feds won’t tell us the exact number. Either way, availability is on a first-come, first-served basis. Once they are gone, they’re gone.

The second “catch” can be a bit of a pain for many rural Americans. This is rather ironic, since those in rural areas are the ones most directly affected by over the air signal reception of DTV signals. In a nutshell, you will have to give the government a physical “street” mailing address in order to get your coupons mailed to you. You can NOT use a PO Box as a mailing address. You can NOT use a business address to send your coupons to. You can NOT use a service such as Mailboxes, Etc., The UPS Store or other private mailbox provider. You can NOT have the coupons shipped to you overseas or to any domestic address that does not match-up with a (very buggy) database of residential addresses maintained by the U.S. Postal Service. This is a rather unforgiving process, unfortunately. You will need to enter your street address information EXACTLY as it appears in the USPS database, otherwise your application will be rejected. So, what do you do if you live in a remote area and you do not have a “street address” that is serviced by the U.S. Postal Service? At this point, insofar as we can tell, you are just out of luck. Sorry.

The same goes for any legitimate street address that the USPS has “mucked-up” in their database. From previous experience, I can tell you that this database is horribly inaccurate in many cases. For example, the business address that I have used for 10 years to receive postal mail, UPS shipments, FedEx deliveries, freight deliveries, my income tax and voting materials, driver’s license, etc. does not exist at all in the USPS database. Funny, I still get mail there every single day though. Go figure! In cases like this, you may want to try calling their toll-free phone number at 1-888-DTV-2009 instead, since you will not get anywhere with the online application system.

So, you’ve called or filled-out the DTV converter box application online. Now, what? Sit. Wait. Check your mailbox again, and be prepared to wait a bit longer. A very informal survey we did recently indicated that it took approximately 20-30 days for consumers to receive their DTV converter box coupons in the mail. You will eventually receive a standard sized #10 envelope with a couple of pages of information and (usually) two “coupons”. They don’t look like your average coupon though. They look more like credit cards. There is a mag stripe on the back of each plastic card, as well as a serial number on the front. The mailing will most likely come from TV Converter Box Coupon Program, PO Box 2000, Portland, OR 97208-2000.

The first page (see above) contains your name and address, the coupon(s) and a list of local retailers where you can supposedly buy a CECB digital TV converter box. These locations are most likely automatically generated from a database that matches your zip code to that of nearby registered CECB converter box retailers. It is far from a complete list though. The one we received (see above) listed eight locations in Humboldt County where the digital television converters are available. They consisted of SEARS, Radio Shack, K-Mart and Target. We do not have a Best Buy, Circuit City, Wal-Mart or a number of other participating electronics chain stores in our area, or they most likely would have been listed first.

The second page (see left) contains some general information about the DTV converter box program. This page also has a list of the most recently approved CECB DTV converter box models that are eligible for the program, although we are guessing that the list will probably be less than 100% up-to-date by the time you get it. Lastly, the insert contains a list of about a dozen or so mail order and online retailers that will accept the coupons and who presumably have the decoders in stock. If you want to read the entire list, see the end of this article for a link to download a digital copy of the insert, which you can print out for yourself.

Lastly, and most importantly!!! If you take away only a single fact to remember from this entire article, it should definitely be to take a close look at the expiration date on each coupon. At most, you will only have 90 days in order to use your $40 DTV converter coupons before they expire. Once they expire, they are absolutely worthless. The government will not give you an extension or re-issue you new coupons. In other words, use them, or lose them! You have 90 days to use the coupons from the day the coupons are printed, NOT from the day that you receive them. As with most bulk mailers, this agency quite likely only sends out their mailings once per week in order to get a bulk discount from the U.S. Postal Service. So, you may find that up to two weeks has been shaved off the 90 days you have to spend the coupons by the time you actually receive them. The government has caught quite a bit of flack over the entire 90 day expiration date issue, but it’s too late for them to make any changes to the program at this point. So, buyer (and taxpayer) beware!

Below are links to graphic copies of the materials you will receive once you register to receive your free government Digital Television (DTV) converters, or CECB boxes. They have been “Photoshopped” to remove certain parts of the serial numbers. Needless to say, you can’t just print these pages out on your inkjet printer and try to pass them off as real coupons. Each DTV converter box coupon has it’s own individual serial number and mag stripe. The information on these pages is for reference and display purposes only.

Free DTV Coupon Insert Page1

Free DTV Coupon Insert Page 2

We will soon publish an updated list of online retailers that can actually process the $40 DTV digital converter box coupons via the Internet. Most online retailers have no way to accept these coupons at present, and most likely never will. A handful of companies have stepped forward to fill this gap, and they are the only ones you should consider buying from online, since you will most likely be overcharged (no discount given) if you try ordering from a merchant that hasn’t made special provisions to deal with these specific coupons.

UPDATE: President Obama and the U.S. Congress officially extended the deadline for broadcasters to switch to DTV to June 12, 2009. You can keep applying for coupons via phone or the Internet until that time. Keep in mind that the extension is basically voluntary, meaning that broadcasters can switch their signals to DTV and STOP broadcasting in analog anytime that they want to. There are very few stations that are waiting until June to make the jump to DTV, due to the high cost associated with simulcasting both digital and analog signals. So, chances are that the only analog broadcasts still remaining in your area are most likely that of translators and low-power (LPTV) stations, which are not required to transition to digital, anyway.

Stay tuned!!!

Date: Thu, May 22, 2008 3:23 pm
To: tom@teletruth.org
Subject: “A View from the Digital Divide DTV Front”

I’m not really sure how to address the issues in the article, so I’ll just try making a few points and suggestions below. Many, if not most, of these points would not be understood by the average consumer, but that’s another matter:

Mistake #1 - Buying a converter at Best Buy. You are far better off buying online or via mail order from a company that specializes in broadcast or Over The Air (OTA) antennas than purchasing one art a mass market retailer like Best Buy. Probably the best place you can shop is at solidsignal.com . They have a wide range of boxes, many of which are cheaper than the one you purchased in the article. They also have excellent customer service and can make some useful suggestions by phone. You can also compare a number of boxes on websites such as amazon.com as well.

Mistake #2 - Listening to a salesperson at Radio Shack. Let’s face it, if someone really knew a lot about local broadcasting, they probably wouldn’t be working at Radio Shack to begin with. The suggestion for you to buy an in-line amplifier to solve your problem of lack of signal strength was just plain stupid. Radio Shack is no place to look for expert advice.

Mistake #3 - Looking for antenna installers. If you couldn’t find a few hundred antenna installers in the state of New Jersey, you were definitely looking in the wrong place. If you are going to use the Yellow Pages, try looking under “satellite television”. The satellite installers that have been around for a long time also commonly install broadcast reception antennas as well. They just don’t want to spend the money on advertising to the small audience that buys OTA antennas. In particular, look for a dealer that does more than just DirecTV or DISH Network only. The dealers that install C-Band dishes and do commercial installs are your best bet. They will know the inside scoop on your local broadcasters better than anyone at Radio Shack.

Mistake #4 - $300 for an outdoor antenna??? I’m not sure what antenna you bought, but if you are doing a self-installation it should not cost anywhere near that much. I bought my own OTA antenna from solidsignal.com and paid around $75. That antenna is longer than I am tall and provides far better reception than most people would ever need. Unless you are running more than 100′+ of coaxial cable, you shouldn’t need an amp and the rest of the costs (cable, connectors) are pretty minimal. It might be cheaper to figure out EXACTLY how much cable you need, then buy it by the foot at a local hardware store, rather than buying a whole spool or a 100′ length with the connectors already crimped on.

Mistake #5 - Assuming that the signal you get today is similar to the one you will get after analog broadcasting is phased out. The fact is, very few people are actually watching their TV via digital Over The Air broadcasts right now. Most of them are still tuning in the analog channels or get their signal from the cable TV company or by satellite. The broadcasters know this. Since many broadcasters are still “toying” with HDTV, quite a number of them are only broadcasting a digital signal on limited schedules or are using limited transmitter power to save money on electricity at the moment. After all, if they are simulcasting both digital and analog signals at the same time using the same amount of power they are having to pay DOUBLE the electric bill, which is a big concern for many small stations. I think you’ll find that once the old analog signals go away, you will see broadcasters start firing up their transmitters at full power. It makes quite a difference when a broadcaster goes from a minimal 50 Watts to a full 200,000 Watts.

Mistake #6 - Expecting to get the same number of channels that are on analog. I’m sure that there are quite a number of low-power (LPTV) channels that will never make the conversion to digital, because they simply can’t afford transmitters at this point. Quite a number of other stations simply don’t have their digital systems set up yet, or are only broadcasting on a limited basis. Quite a few of them will likely wait right up until the last minute to make the transition. Until then, you should still be able to receive them on analog. Bottom line… Don’t take “overlap” of analog and digital for granted! Expect one or the other, but don’t expect to get a perfect signal from both. After all, it’s not like you are actually going to watch BOTH the analog and digital version of the same channel.

Mistake #7 - Forgetting the past. People these days quite simply take getting a decent TV signal with little or nothing for an antenna for granted. It wasn’t always that way, nor was it ever intended to be that easy to get a picture. In the early years of TV broadcasting, an outdoor antenna was almost always required, but people weren’t complaining about it back then. The only reason that it is so easy to get a signal with “rabbit ears” these days is because the shift from TV receivers using tubes to solid-state technology has made pulling-in a watchable picture infinitely easier. Solid-state amplifiers are much more sensitive and produce much less “noise” than vacuum tubes. If you tried plugging-in a circa 1940′s TV set in the same location you are in right now with rabbit ears, you wouldn’t get any picture at all. If anything, it cost far MORE to buy a TV and antenna (when you take inflation into account) back in the “old days” than it does today. Broadcasters are already pumping out signals using hundreds of thousands of watts of power. It’s the consumer’s job to turn it into a watchable picture. TV was not initially designed to be that easy to pick up. Older Americans would probably be the first to remember this. To be honest, today’s generation has been rather spoiled after growing up with cable TV or satellite television. Over The Air reception will never compete with those technologies when it comes to how easy it is to get a “perfect” picture.

Mistake #8 - FCC testing of HDTV converter boxes. ALL boxes sold in the U.S. have to be granted FCC type acceptance prior to being imported into the country or sold. Some companies have gone through the additional steps of getting their products “certified” for use with the coupon program as well. As for “practical” testing, there really is no need for it. Nothing that happens in the world of broadcasting is anything more than a matter of math. An engineer can tell you exactly what signal level to expect at a specific location well prior to hitting the transmit switch. Most products these days are only “simulated” before going into mass production. Even airplanes. The FCC has already “done the math” on the issue and broadcast engineers have already calculated the specs each broadcaster would need to get the same coverage as they had previously and what specs receivers would have to meet in order to receive them. There is no guess work going on here. It is simple math.

Mistake #9 - I wouldn’t exactly call this a mistake, but more of a reality check. All electronics products eventually become obsolete. Some sooner than others. Just ask anyone who has owned a Betamax (or any VCR, for that matter), video disc player, CD mini-disc player, Digital Audio Tape players, 8-Tracks, cassette players, 78 RPM record players, Windows 95 or any number of other examples. Some products far, far more expensive than portable television sets have been pulled from the market after as little as a few months in the past. How about all of the people that rushed out at bought non Blu-Ray HD-DVD players are getting their money back? TV sets purchased in the late 1930′s still work today (albeit in black and white). I’d say that most of these people have gotten their money’s worth by now.

Let’s not forget that the broadcasters themselves are being forced to shell out millions of dollars on new equipment, and that the FCC has pushed back the final switchover date on HDTV numerous, numerous times in the past at their request. It’s either now or never. The rest of the world is passing us by. The previous delays have already led to our version of HDTV being a half-baked solution compared to newer technology. Let’s just get on with it. I hope you find some of this info useful.